Imagine the thrill of the college football season building to its grandest moment—crowning the year's top player with the prestigious Heisman Trophy. But here's where it gets controversial: with only one non-quarterback among the finalists and zero defenders, is the Heisman Trophy truly representing the full spectrum of game-changing talent on the field? Dive into the latest buzz as we unveil the 2025 finalists announced during ESPN’s Monday Night Countdown, and explore what this selection might mean for the future of the award.
The 2025 Heisman Memorial Trophy finalists were revealed live on ESPN’s Monday Night Countdown show, which aired from 6 to 8 p.m. ET tonight. You can catch up on the excitement via the Heisman website and their social media channels too. For those new to the Heisman, it's essentially college football's equivalent of the MVP award, honoring the player who best exemplifies excellence on the gridiron—think standout performances, leadership, and impact on the game.
Mark your calendars for the upcoming ceremony: it's set for December 13th at 7:00 p.m. ET, broadcast live on ABC. And if you're a playoff fan, the College Football Playoff kicks off just a week later on December 19th, featuring some of these very finalists in action. This adds an extra layer of anticipation, as we'll see how these players perform under even brighter lights.
This year, the committee narrowed it down to just four finalists, a mix that's sparked some debate. Interestingly, three of them are quarterbacks, with only one non-quarterback making the cut—and notably, no defensive players at all. For beginners wondering about this, quarterbacks often dominate because their role as the offense's leader allows for flashy stats like passing yards and touchdowns, but critics argue this overlooks the unsung heroes on defense who prevent scores and change the game's momentum. And this is the part most people miss: could expanding the criteria to include more positions lead to a more balanced and exciting award? Let's take a closer look at each of these rising stars headed to New York.
First up is Jeremiyah Love, a running back from Notre Dame. As the lone non-quarterback on the list, Love stands out as a trailblazer, proving that skill positions beyond the QB can shine brightly. He powered the Fighting Irish to a solid 10-2 record, racking up career-high stats all season long. With Notre Dame choosing not to play in a bowl game, his college career wraps up this year, setting the stage for an intriguing transition to the NFL. Love's numbers are impressive: 1,372 rushing yards, 18 rushing touchdowns, a robust 6.9 yards per carry, plus versatility as a receiver with 27 catches for 280 yards and three more touchdowns. Imagine a player who can dominate on the ground and in the air—what a challenge for future defenses!
Next, Fernando Mendoza, the quarterback for Indiana. This duo turned heads with a flawless 13-0 season, clinching a thrilling 13-10 victory over Ohio State to secure the Big Ten Championship—the Hoosiers' first in nearly 60 years! It's a historic achievement that highlights how one player's precision can elevate an entire team. Mendoza and Indiana will carry that momentum into the College Football Playoff as the No. 1 seed, where they'll face elite competition. His stats reflect a standout campaign: 2,980 passing yards, an FBS-leading 33 touchdowns, just six interceptions, and a 71.5% completion percentage. For newcomers to football analytics, that completion percentage shows how efficiently he connected with receivers, minimizing mistakes and maximizing opportunities.
Then there's Diego Pavia, quarterback for Vanderbilt. Pavia's journey this season has been nothing short of remarkable, culminating in a memorable 'Heisman moment' during the final week against Tennessee—complete with striking the iconic pose! As a dual-threat QB, he masterminded the Commodores' 10-2 record, coming agonizingly close to playoff contention. His regular season totals paint a picture of versatility: 3,192 passing yards, 27 passing touchdowns, eight interceptions, a 71.2% completion rate, 826 rushing yards, and nine rushing touchdowns. This exemplifies the modern QB who can keep defenses guessing, blending aerial assaults with ground threats.
Finally, Julian Sayin, the quarterback from Ohio State. While the Big Ten Championship didn't go their way, Sayin delivered a season worthy of Heisman consideration, guiding the Buckeyes to a strong 12-1 record and a No. 2 seed in the College Football Playoff. As a redshirt freshman stepping into the starting role, his first-year impact was undeniable. Stats-wise, he threw for 3,329 yards, 31 touchdowns, six interceptions, and an FBS-leading 78.4% completion percentage—demonstrating pinpoint accuracy that kept Ohio State's offense humming.
Get the Daily On3 Newsletter in your inbox every morning.
By clicking "Subscribe to Newsletter", I agree to On3's Privacy Notice (https://www.on3.com/page/privacy-policy/), Terms (https://www.on3.com/page/terms-of-service/), and use of my personal information described therein.
As we wrap up, it's worth pondering: Does the Heisman's QB-heavy slant truly capture the essence of college football, or should we advocate for broader recognition of other positions? What if defensive standouts or special teams wizards got a shot—would that change the trophy's legacy? Share your thoughts in the comments: Do you agree with these finalists, or think someone else deserves the spotlight? And here's a controversial twist—maybe the award should evolve to include team impact beyond individual stats, like how a linebacker can single-handedly turn a game's tide. What's your take? Let's discuss!
